Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Should Children of 'Posthumous Conception' Get Benefits?

Should Children of 'Posthumous Conception' Get Benefits?

Transcript by www.newsy.com BY BREANA JONES ANCHOR CHRISTINA HARTMAN A Florida man dies. His wife freezes his sperm and eighteen months later has a set of twins. Now those kids want Social Security benefits but Social Security says no. Then a federal appeals court said yes. Now it's up to the Supreme Court. It's Astrue V. Capato, and opening arguments were heard on Monday. CNN has details. "The justices clearly appeared at odds over how to treat this relatively new category of offspring, and whether they should be in the same category as stepchildren or adopted children when deciding survivor benefits." Karen Capato wants Social Security benefits for her twins, because they are biologically her husband's. But the Supreme Court says the question here is not whether the twins are Mr. Capato's but whether they were his dependents. Fox News explains. "The children were not alive at the time of dad's death ... If the kids are not alive the government argues they cannot be deemed ! dependent per the statute." NPR has another way to look at it, saying the government is arguing... "...posthumously conceived children fall outside the class of children entitled to survivors benefits because 'they were brought into being by a surviving parent with the knowledge that the deceased biological parent will not be able to contribute wages for their support.' " In-vitro fertilization is nothing new, but the Surpreme Court is referencing a social security regulation from 1939. The Los Angeles ...





0 comments: